Bert McCoy's
"MyTeaching Resources"
English 9-12
  • Home
    • Home #2
    • Home #3
    • Education >
      • The Smartest Thing You Can Do for Yourself Today (You Won’t Regret It) Written by Marc Chernoff
      • 16 Things I Wished I Had Learned Early
      • Top 10 Rules for Success
      • Thoughts on Teaching
      • Five Methods to Notetaking
      • How To Listen
      • The Socratic Method
      • Differentiated Instruction Depth and Complexity
      • How to be attractive to others
      • 12 Things Enormously Successful People Refuse to Do
      • How much sleep to successful people get?
      • Hack Life
      • Note To Self/ Letter to Self
      • Quotes on Education
      • Classroom Rules and Expectations
      • Procrastination
    • Writing and Vocabulary >
      • SAT Writing Prep Questions
      • How to Change Your Thoughts
      • Tips to writing short stories
      • Vocabulary (SAT 100)
      • CAHSEE Vocab/Mix
      • SAT/ Vocabulary #2
      • Vocabulary SAT/CAHSEE/CST
      • Sat Vocabulary Words
      • CAHSEE Prep
      • Vocabulary Roots
      • How to write a literature review
      • Thesis Statements
      • MLA Formatting
      • Writing a Business Letter
      • Figurative Language
      • Plot Structure
      • Transition Word List >
        • Transition Word List
        • Transition Word List
      • Literature Terms >
        • Literature Terms
        • Glossary of Literature Terms
        • Literary Elements
        • Forshadowing
      • Context Clues
      • Mysteries of vernacular
      • Vocabulary Prefix
      • Vocabulary Suffix
      • How to run faster!
    • Reading >
      • Audiobooks
      • Audiobooks on line
      • Best Books to Read
      • Free Books on Line >
        • Free Books
        • e-books
      • Digital Citizenship 2014/2015 >
        • Digital Literacy 1
        • Digital Citizenship Curriculum Lesson 1
        • Digital Literacy
      • Science Fiction & Fantasy Stories (Tor.com)
      • Noble Prise in Literature >
        • Russian writers
    • Some Favorite Songs
    • Some Favorite UFO Video Clips
    • Best Teacher Apps For High School, Middle, & Elementary School >
      • Best EdTech 2014 Websites
    • Cool Websites to Visit >
      • Best i-phone/Android Editing Apps >
        • Storyboards
      • 50 Unique and Useful Websites on the Internet
      • How to Become an Early Riser
      • 100 Tech Hacks
      • 10 Nonf-iction Books to blow Your Mind
      • Roman Numerals and More...
      • Get Almost any Book For Free
    • The Journey of Purpose >
      • youarecreators
      • Absolute Motivation #1 >
        • Absolute Motivation #2
    • Business World Material >
      • Peaceful Warrior Quotes
      • Goal-setting
      • Less Brown
      • Who Move My Cheese >
        • Who Moved My Cheese/ #1
        • Who Moved My Cheese/ #2
        • Who Moved My Cheese/ #3
      • Secrets of Success
      • Did You Know?
      • The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People
      • The Four Agreements: >
        • The Four Agreements
      • John Wooden's, "Pyramid of Success"
    • State Standards 12th Grade
  • Teaching Stories
    • Teaching Stories/ Quotes >
      • Spiritual Paths
    • Mooji Stories
    • "The Emperor's Three Questions" by Leo Tolstoy
    • Avadhuta Gita >
      • Avadhuta Gita
    • Teaching Stories
    • Mullah Nasruddin Stories >
      • Teaching Stories/Idries Shah
    • The Bhagavad Gita vs "To be or not to be." >
      • The Bhagavad-Gita
    • Vedanta Teachings >
      • Advaita / Nonduality Quotes
      • Advaita
    • The Emerald Tablets/Alchemist
    • Aesop's Fables
    • Koans
    • The Oarsman
    • The American Tourist Story
    • The Violinist
    • The Moth Presents
    • inspirational Stories
  • Cool Quotes
    • Rumi Quotes >
      • Non-Dual Quotes
      • Present Moment Quotes
    • Inspirational Quotations 1
    • Inspirational Quotations 2
    • Cool QUOTES!
    • Motivational Quotes
    • Wisdom
  • Film Studies 2019-2020
    • Film Study Syllabus >
      • Film Study Terms
      • Film Vocabulary 2
    • Parasite Film
    • Arrival Film
    • Film Posters >
      • Denis Villeneuve
    • Film Studies Films >
      • Movies for Film Class
    • Film History/The Lumiere Brothers and more...
    • Film Making Quotes >
      • I-Movie Information
      • Lucy Film
      • First Films of Great Directors >
        • Editing (Cuts)
        • Federico Fellini
        • Jean-Luc Godard
        • Screenplay Theme
      • Hollywood Casting and Film
      • Sam Mendes 1917 Film
      • Rotten Tomatoes Best films
      • Screenwriting Sample Scrips
    • Movie Etiquette >
      • Character Types
      • Turner Classic Movies
      • Free Movies
      • Pulp Fiction Film
    • Film Agenda 2019-2020 >
      • Permission Letter
      • Filmmaking and Advice
      • Breaking Into Hollywood
      • Film Schools
      • Filmsite
    • Film Quotes >
      • The 100 greatest movie quotes of all time
    • Cinematography >
      • Film Shots
      • Camera Shots
    • Famous Film Directors >
      • Directors Favorite Films
      • John Ford
      • Jean-Luc Godard >
        • Breathless >
          • Breathless
      • François Truffaut
      • Female Film Directors
      • Akira Kurosawae
      • Andrei Tarkovsky
      • David Fincher
      • Christopher Nolan
      • Fassbinder Films
      • Coen Brothers
      • Martin Scorsese
      • Steven Speilberg
      • Quentin Tarantino
      • Directors/Producers
      • Andrei Tarkovsky
      • Stanly Kubrick >
        • Stanley Kubrick
      • The Wachowskis
    • The Seven Stages of Film Production
    • Austin Film Festival
    • Sundance Film Winners >
      • Sundance Film Festival
    • Inside The Actor's Studio
    • Television Studies
    • Screenwriting Tips >
      • How to Writing a Screenplay
    • Narrative Design and Terms >
      • Film Study Narrative Design
      • The Hero's Journey >
        • What is an Archetype?
        • Hero's Journey
        • The Hero's Journey #1
        • Hero's Journey #2
        • Hero's Journey #3
      • Mise En Scene >
        • Mise En Scene
      • Peaky Blinders
      • Peaceful Warrior Reviews >
        • Peaceful Warrior
        • Peaceful Warrior Quotes
        • Peaceful Warrior Script
        • Peaceful Warrior
      • Groundhog Day >
        • Time Loop Films
        • If today was your last day?
        • Discussion Questions Film Studies
        • Character Counts Film Studies
      • The OA
      • The Legend of Bagger Vance/The Gita >
        • Production Notes Legend of Bagger Vance
      • Meet Joe Black >
        • Death Takes A Holiday 1934
      • Alfred Hitchcock >
        • Alfred Hitchcock
        • Alfred Hitchcock Presnts
        • Dial M for Murder
        • Psycho >
          • Psycho 1960
          • Ed Gain Psycho
        • The Birds
        • Rear Window 1954 >
          • Disturbia
        • Vertigo >
          • Vertigo 1958
        • Rope
        • To Catch a Thief
        • Notorious 1946
        • Strangers on a Train 1951
        • North by Northwest 1959
        • To Catch a Thief/ Hitchcock
        • The 39 Steps 1935
        • The Lady Vanishes 1938
      • Marathon Man
      • Poltergeist >
        • Poltergeist
      • Jaws >
        • Jaws
      • 2001: A Space Odyssey >
        • Stanley Kubric
      • 100-Foot Journey >
        • French Laundry Restaurant
        • The Hundred Foot Journey
        • 100 Foot Journey
      • Ratatouille >
        • Ratatouille Quotes
      • Close Encounters of the Third Kind
      • Documentary >
        • Basquiat
        • The Secret
        • Sicko
        • Where To Invade Next (Compare Contrast Writing Assignment)
        • filmumentaries
        • 200 Free Documentaries
      • 42 The Jackie Robinson Story
      • It's A Wonderful Life >
        • it's a Wonderful Life
        • It's a Wonderful Life #2
        • It's A Wonderful Life Screenplay PDF
      • I Am Legend
      • The Matrix >
        • The Matrix Reloaded
        • The Matrix The Animatrix
      • Inception
      • Avatar
      • War of the Worlds >
        • H.G. Wells
        • War of The Worlds Vocabulary
        • War of the Worlds 2
      • Forever Strong Rugby >
        • Forever Strong
        • History of Rugby
      • Hoosiers >
        • Hoosiers
      • Goal The Dream Begins
      • Aliens and Cowboys >
        • The Good, The Bad, and the Ugly
      • Film Noir >
        • 12 Angry Men 1957
        • Casablanca >
          • Casablanca
          • Casablanca Review
        • Film Noir >
          • Film Noir Titles
        • Strangers on a Train/ Hitchcock >
          • Strangers on a Train/ Hitchcock
        • The Maltese Falcon
      • Charlie Chaplin >
        • Charlie Chaplin
        • New Page
      • JFK Assassination 1 >
        • Robert Yeoman
        • JFK/Oliver Stone
        • JFK Assassination 2
        • Robert Richardson and JfK >
          • Digital Cinema Show
      • Miracle >
        • Flow
      • Patch Adams >
        • Patch Adams 2
      • Gattaca >
        • Eugenics
        • Gattaca
        • Gattaca filming Locations
      • Point Break
      • The Dark Knight >
        • Batman 1
        • Batman 2
      • Inception
      • Finding Forrester
      • The Ring
      • Blade Runner 2049 >
        • Blade Runner
      • Rocky >
        • Top 25 Cult Films:
        • Screenwriting software
        • How to Write for TV
      • Films To Consider: >
        • Breathless, by Jean-Luc Godard (1960)
        • Interstellar
        • What Dreams May Come
        • Powder
        • Forrest Gump
        • Mr. Holland's Opus >
          • Vimeo Short Films
          • Sketchbooks for Class
        • The Shining
        • Breakfast at Tiffiffany's
        • Indiana Jones
        • Rain Man
        • French Kiss
        • Silence of the Lambs
        • The Hunger Games/Quotes >
          • Suzanne Collins
          • The Hunger Games
          • The Hunger Games
          • The Hunger Games Seneca
          • The Hunger Games/ Questions
          • Catching Fire
          • The Hunger Games
          • The Hunger Games/ Chapters
          • The Hunger Games/ Characters, Facts, Themes,
        • The Last Samurai
        • In the Mood for Love
        • Seabiscuit
        • Malcolm X
        • 3 Days of the Condor 1975
        • Das Boot
        • Crimson Tide
        • U-571
        • The Hunt For Red October
        • Mr. & Mrs. Smith
        • Promised Land
        • Wonder Woman 2017
        • Planet of the Apes Films
        • The Secret Life of Walter Mitty
        • A Fist Full of Dollars
        • The Conformist >
          • The Conformist
        • Peter Sellers
        • Gladiator
        • The Last Emperor 1987/ Bertolucci
        • Phenomenon 1996
        • Back to the Future
        • The Butler
        • Contagion 2011
        • Speed Racer
        • The Rainmaker
        • Remember the Titans
        • In the Mood for Love
        • 1984 George Orwell
        • Lord of the Rings Films
      • Citizen Kane >
        • Citizen Kane #2
      • The Perks of Being a Wallflower
      • They're Here!
      • The Wild Wild West! >
        • John Wayne / True Grit
        • Clint Eastwood/ High Plains Drifter
      • The Pride of the Yankees 1943
    • German Expressionism in Film >
      • Fritz Lang
      • Dadaist Films
    • Film as Social and Cultural History
    • Filmmaker IQ
    • National Archive Films
    • Atlas Shrugged /Ayn Rand
    • 2016-17 Film Play List
    • Scary Movies >
      • Horror
      • Flowers in the Attic/ Parental Responsibilities
      • Ghost of the Lagoon by Armstrong Sperry
      • Frankenstein 1910 Silent Movie
      • Free Movies
      • My Favorite Directors...Best Directors >
        • My Favorite Actors
    • Dreamworks
    • How to find the theme (s)
    • Man vs Nature Films
    • Film Studies
    • Film Set Lingo
    • Film Studies Lectures
    • Sound Design
    • Film Sound
    • Film Editing
    • Film Lighting Terms and Techniques >
      • Film Lighting
    • Acting Techniques
    • James Bond
    • Film Studies/ Film as Literature (FAL) >
      • filmsite.org
      • Classics Movies #1 >
        • Classic Movies #2
      • Buster Keaton
      • Buster keaton vs Charlie Chaplin
      • Sidney Portier Movies
    • Film Techniques and Terminology
    • Zorba the Greek
    • The Hollywood Reporter
    • Education Movies
    • WAR!
    • Braveheart
    • Glory Road
    • Historical and Period Drama Movies
    • Marlon Brando/On The Water-front
    • Mutiny on the Bounty
    • Stages and Archetypes of the Hero's Journey
    • October Sky
    • Spy Movies
    • Stephen Fry
    • Paper Towns
    • From Weak to Strong Movies
    • The Secret Life of Bees
    • Environmental Movies
    • Sports Movies >
      • A River That Runs Through It >
        • Fly Fishing Quotes
      • Money Ball >
        • Money Ball #2
      • Dogville
      • Goal / History of soccer >
        • Goal (page two)
      • Teamwork Movies
      • www.ronaldothefilm.com
      • We Are Marshall
      • Pele
      • Chariots of Fire
      • Remember the Titans
    • Lance Armstrong Doping
    • FAL/ ?
    • Madame Bovary
  • English 9 Curriculum Map 2018-19
    • Siddhartha >
      • Siddhartha Vocabulary Words
    • English 9 Unit 1 >
      • Video Games >
        • Video Gaming
        • Video Games #2
        • Game Programmer
        • Video Game Jobs
        • Video Games/Presi/Slideshare
      • Video Games
      • Story Telling /Moth
      • 10 Rules/Carmichael
    • The Cast of Amontillado
    • The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian >
      • The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian Vocabulary Words
    • Direct and Indirect Characterization
    • Overly Sarcastic Productions The Classics
    • English 9 Unit 2 >
      • Food >
        • BBC Fast Food Baby
        • BBC The Truth About Food
        • BBC Beef Burgers
        • GMOs
        • Food
        • Food
        • Food
      • Richard Wright/Blackboy >
        • Black Boy by Richard Wright
      • The Age of the Essay Paul Graham
    • English 9 Unit 3 >
      • Siddhartha >
        • Siddhartha
        • The Odyssey Vocabulary Words >
          • The Odyssey Movie
          • Create a Myth Assignment
          • Odyssey Timelines/ AWESOME!
          • Odyssey Audio
          • The Odyssey/60 Second Recap
          • Freewill vs Determinism quotes
          • Freewill vs Determinism
          • Greek Gods
          • Greek Vases
          • Ancient Greeks
          • Greek Gods
          • The Greeks/Gods
          • Greek Gods/Godesses
          • Greek Gods and their Characteristics
          • Greek Gods/Videos
          • Odyssey
          • The Odyssey and the Hero's Journey
          • The Odyssey Presentations
      • Greek and Roman >
        • Untitled
        • What is theater?
        • Ancient Rome
        • The Gladiator Graveyard
        • Spartacus Behing the Myth
        • Helen of Troy
        • Worst Jobs Roman/Anglo-Saxon
        • Ancient Greek/Roman Music
        • Ancient Greek Homes
        • Rome/History/BBC >
          • Marcus Aurelius
          • The Stoics
          • Metal Detecting Roman/Greek
        • Oedipus The King >
          • Oedipus the King/Prezi
        • Homer, The Iliad
        • The Norse Gods
    • English 9 Unit 4 >
      • Graffiti >
        • Bansky
        • Bansky Art Sold fo
        • Street Art
        • The Top Street and Graffiti Artists to Watch in 2015
        • Graffiti Analysis
        • Anamorphic Graffiti Illusions by Odeith – Fubiz
    • Romeo and Juliet
    • English 9 Unit 5/ Poetry >
      • Various Poets
    • English 9 Other >
      • English 9 Essay
  • English 12 2017-18
    • Restorative Justice >
      • Juvenile Justice Essay Resources
      • Adam Foss
      • Racial Profiling >
        • Racial Poetry
        • Racial Profiling
      • Racism
      • Bullying #1
      • Race/Racism/Bullying
      • Jim Crow Museum
      • What Would You Do?
      • Bullying
      • Bullying
    • Eng 12/ Life after high school >
      • Personal Statement
      • Vision Board Assignment >
        • Vision Board Project
      • UC Writing Prompts/Journals
      • Hidden Intellectualism by Gerald Graff
      • Job Applications/Business Letter
      • Interview Questions and Answers >
        • Interview Q & A
        • Interview Q & A
      • Job Seeking/Resume/Q and A
      • FAFSA
      • Siddhartha by Hermann Hesse
    • Unit 2 Week (3-5) "College Application Essay" >
      • Commencement Speeches #1
      • Commencement Speeches #2
      • Great Speeches
    • Zoot Suit >
      • Zoot Suit 2
    • 1984 Language, Gendetr, and Culture in George Orwell's 1984 >
      • 1984 Key facts, characters, themes, motifs, and symbolism
    • Brave New World 2016 >
      • Brave New World 2017 1
      • Gender, Language, and Identity
      • Brave New World Character Name meanings
      • BNW Vocabulary
      • BNW Chomsky
      • Brave New World Vocabulary Words
      • Brave New World 2016 2
      • The Perennial Philosophy/Huxly
      • Mystic Quotes
      • Papaji Advaita Vedanta
      • Nissargadatta
      • Vedanta Advaita Quotes
      • Kristnamurti Quotes
      • Sola BNW
      • Iron Maiden/ BNW
    • Into The Wild 2016-17
    • Into the Wild/ 11/15 >
      • Into the Wild/ Characters >
        • Into The Wild/Characters >
          • Into the Wild/Themes, Characters
      • Into the Wild/ Vocab
      • Into the Wild/ Quotes
      • into The Wild/ Chapter Reviews
      • Into The Wild/ Symbolism
      • Into To Wild/ Themes
      • Into The Wild/ Glossary
      • Into the Wild/ Quiz 1
      • Into the Wild/Jon Krakauer >
        • Is Ignorance Bliss?
        • Into the Wild/ Essential questions
        • Into the Wild/20/20 >
          • Into the Wild/Eckhart Tolle
        • Chris McCandless Articles/Outside Magazine
        • Into the Wild/Jon Krakaur
        • Into the Wild/2015/Nomads
        • Into the Wild
        • Into the Wild/The Big Two-hearted River/Nick Adams
        • Into the Wild/Who Am I
        • Into the Wild/Pierre Bezuhov/From War and Peace
        • Into The Wild/Various
        • Into the Wild/2015/Rush
        • Into the Wild/Tolstoy
        • Into the Wild/Springsteen
        • Into the Wild/Jack London
        • Into the Wild/Emerson
        • To Build a Fire/Jack Londen
        • Into the Wild/Louis L' Amour
        • Into the Wild/Thoreau
        • Into the Wild/Boris Pasternak
        • Into the Outdoors
        • Into the Wild/Alaska Denali
        • Into the Wild/Snowboarding
        • Into the Wild/2014/15/Supertramp
        • Into the Wild/Vocabulary
        • Into The Wild/Themes >
          • Into the Wild/Themes
        • Into The Wild/Glossary
        • Into the Wild/ Papaji
        • Into the Wild/Eckhart Tolle
        • Into the Wild
        • Into the Wild (Prezi)
        • Into the Wild/John Muir
        • Into the Wild/Quiz
        • Into the Wild /Movie Questions
        • Into the Wild/ Q&A
        • Into the Wild/ Climbing Videos
        • Into the Wild/Moose
    • Standards
    • English 12 Syllabus
    • English 12 2016-17 >
      • English 12a Final Essay
      • Letter To Myself >
        • Letter to Myself
        • Letter to Myself
    • English 12 Essay 2015
    • History of the English Church >
      • History of English
      • History of English
      • The History of English >
        • BBC Anglo-Saxons >
          • Anglo Saxons >
            • Anglo Saxon Lyre
            • Anglo-Saxon The History of English
            • Worst Jobs in History (Middle Ages)
            • The Worst Jobs in History--The Dark Age - Part 1-6
            • The Worst Jobs In History - 1x03 - Tudor
            • The Worst Jobs In History--Roman & Anglo-Saxon
            • The Worst Jobs In History--Medieval
            • The Worst Jobs In History--Tudor
            • The Worst Jobs In History--Stuart
            • The Worst Jobs In History--Georgian
            • The Worst Jobs In History--Victorian
            • The Worst Jobs In History--Urban
            • The Worst Jobs In History--Royal
            • The Worst Jobs In History-- Industrial
            • The Worst Jobs In History--Maritime
            • The Worst Jobs In History--Rural
            • The Worst Jobs In History--Christmas
            • The Medievil Mind >
              • The Medieval Belief
              • The Medievil Treasures BBC
              • The Medieval Power
              • Age of Conquest
              • The Crusades
              • The Black Plague
              • AEngla Land
              • Treasures of the Anglo-Saxons
              • The Staffordshire Hoard
            • Beowulf >
              • In Search of Beowulf
              • Beowulf PPt Presentations
              • British Literature Learning Videos >
                • Paganism vs Christianity
                • The Germanic Tribes
                • Beowulf & the Anglo-Saxons (1-8)
            • The Canterbury Tales
        • Language
    • English 12 Reading >
      • Epic of Gilgamesh Audio 2000 BC.
      • Sir Gawain and the Green Knight Late 14th-century
      • The Wife of Bath's Tale 1405-1410 from canterbury Tales
      • The Passionate Shepard
      • Shakespeare 1564-1616 >
        • Shakespeare/ Tudor England
        • Novels/Plays >
          • Hamlet's, "To Be or Not to Be"
          • A Midsummer Night's Dream
          • Macbeth
          • Macbeth
          • Macbeth Act by Act
          • Shakespeare Poems
          • Globe Theater
          • Shakespeare Sonnets
          • Sonnet 1
          • Sonnet 1 Blog:
          • Sonnet 18
          • Sonnet 29
          • Sonnet 29 Blog:
          • Sonnet 75
          • Sonnet 75 Blog
          • Sonnet 130
      • Romeo & Juliet/ Shakespeare 4/15 >
        • Romeo & Juliet/ Shmoop Resources
        • Shakespeare Glossary
        • Shakespeare's Globe
        • Quotes about Shakespeare >
          • Shakespeare Quotes
          • Shakespeare Castles
        • Romeo & Juliet/ Characters
        • Romeo & Juliet/ Themes, Motifs, Symbolism
        • Elizabethan Clothing
        • Royal Shakespeare Company
        • Romeo and Juliet 1
        • Romeo and Juliet 2
        • Romeo and Juliet 3
        • Romeo and Juliet/ 60 Second
    • Six Centuries of Verse: Metaphysical & Devotional Poets >
      • Ben Johnson
      • John Donne
      • Andrew Marvell >
        • Jonathan Swift
        • A Modest Proposal
      • To His Coy Mistress
    • Romanticism 1790-1850 >
      • Romantic Spirit
      • Mysticism
      • William Blake
      • William Wordsworth
      • Samuel Taylor Coleridge
      • John Keats
      • Percy Bysshe Shelley
      • Mary Shelley
      • Lord Byron
      • James Joyce
  • My Favorite People
    • Favorite Artists >
      • Brian Dettmer Book Cutting
      • Bansky
      • Julian Schnabel
      • Phillip Guston
      • David Salle
      • Robert Motherwell
      • Picaso
      • Raushenburg
      • Francisco Clemente
      • Joseph Beuys
      • Cy Twombly
      • Jean Michel Basquiat
      • Keith Haring
      • Kenny Scharf
      • Kaws
      • Sun Xun
      • L' Arte
      • Richard Serra
    • AESOP
    • Adyashanti
    • Maya Angelou
    • Jane Austin
    • James Baldwin
    • Bansky Quotes
    • Coleman Barks
    • Joseph Beuys
    • Harold Bloom >
      • Harol Bloom/ How to read and why
    • Jorge Luis Borges
    • Robert Bly 1 >
      • Robert Bly 2
    • David Bowie
    • Ray Bradberry >
      • There Will Come Soft Rains
      • Usher II
      • The Veldt
      • Marionettes Inc.
      • Fehrenheit 451
      • Fahrenheit 451 Vocabulary
      • Fahrenheit 451 Quotes
    • Russell Brand >
      • Russell Brand
    • David Brooks
    • Barbara Brodsky
    • James Brown
    • Buddha >
      • Buddha
    • Warren Buffet
    • James Cameron
    • Albert Camus
    • Jack Canfield
    • George Carlin
    • Lewis Carrol
    • Caroline Casey
    • Paulo Coelho/Alchemist >
      • The Alchemist by
      • Paulo Coelho
    • John Coltrane >
      • John Coltrane
    • Steven Covey >
      • Steven Covey
      • The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People/Steven Covey
    • Charlie Chaplin
    • Noam Chomsky
    • Deepak Chopra >
      • Ask Deepak
      • Deepak Chopra
    • Winston Churchill
    • Mihaly Csikszentmihaly
    • Ram Dass
    • Simone De Beauvoir
    • Anthony De Mello
    • Daniel Dennett
    • Shanti Devi
    • Junot Diaz
    • WALT DISNEY QUOTES
    • Fyodor Dostoyevsky >
      • Fyodor Dostoyevsky/ The Brothers Karamazov
    • Carol Dweck/Mindsets
    • Bob Dylan >
      • Bob Dylan
    • Thomas Edison Quiz
    • Albert Einstein >
      • Albert Einstein
    • T. S. Eliot
    • Ralph Waldo Emerson
    • Jane Eyre
    • Anneliese Marie Frank
    • William Faulkner
    • F Scott Fitsgerald >
      • The Roaring 20's
      • F Scott Fitzgerald 2014-15
      • The Great Gatsby
    • Benjamin Franklin
    • Robert Frost
    • Stephen Fry >
      • Stephen Fry
    • Neil Gaiman
    • Dan Gilbert
    • Malcom Gladwell
    • Johann Wolfgang von Goethe
    • Gurdjieff
    • Steven Hawking /black Holes
    • Hafez/Hafiz #1 >
      • Hafez/Hafiz Poems #2
      • Hafez/Hafiz #3
      • Hafez/Hafiz #4
      • Hafez #5 >
        • Hafiz Poems #7
      • Hafez Poems #6
      • Hafez Poems #8
    • Thich Nhat Hanh
    • Tyrone Hayes
    • Ernest Hemingway
    • Hermann Hesse >
      • Siddhartha Quotes
    • Christopher Hitchens
    • HOU HSIAO-HSIEN
    • Langston Hughes >
      • Langston Hughes/ Poems
      • Langston Hughes
    • Aldous Huxley >
      • Brave New World 4/15 >
        • Secret Societies >
          • The Knights Templar
          • The Freemasons
          • The Rosicrucians
          • The Illuminati
          • The Carbonari
        • BNW/ Chemtrails vs Contrails
        • BNW/ Unit Plan
        • BNW/ 2015
        • BNW/ TED
        • BNW/ William Blake/Doors of Perception
        • BNW/ Details #1
        • BNW/ Details #2
        • BNW/ Soma= DMT?
        • BNW/ Futuristic Movie Trailers
        • BNW/ Dystopia vs Utopia
        • BNW vs 1984
        • BNW/ Orwell vs Huxley
        • BNW/ Noam Chomsky
        • BNW/ Huxley Complete Works
        • BNW/ Vedanta and Huxley
        • BNW/ Advaita Vedanta
        • BNW/ Bohemian Grove
        • BNW/ Corporate Deceit
        • BNW/ Shakespeare and Religion by Huxley
        • BNW/ Geo-Engineering
        • BNW/ About Aldous Huxley
        • BNW/ Doors
        • BNW/ Conspiracy?
        • BNW/1984 Synthetic Telepathy
        • BNW/ May 13th
        • BNW/ Transhumanism
        • BNW/ What is DMT? Soma?
        • BNW/ Psychological Warfare
        • BNW/ NWO
      • Brave New World 2014 >
        • Brave New World 2014 >
          • Brave New World #5 2014
          • Oligarcy
          • Transhumanism
          • Agenda 21
          • Inequality For All
          • Inequality For All
          • Brainwash Update
          • Globalization
        • Brave New World Quotes
        • Brave New World >
          • Brave New World #2
          • Brave New World #3
          • Brave New World #4
          • enotes/Brave New World
          • Brave New World Vocabulary Words
          • Aldous Huxley
          • Bio-Engineering
          • CHEM-TRAILS
          • Genetic Engineering
          • Aldous Huxley
          • Aldous Huxley - Videos
      • Brave New World 1/2015
    • Pir Zia Inayat-Khan/Sufi
    • Phil Jackson
    • Eta James
    • James Joyce
    • Mahatma Ghandhi
    • John Irving
    • Carl Gustav Jung/Interview >
      • C. G. Jung/Quotes
    • Jon Kabat-Zinn
    • Kabir
    • Franz Kafka >
      • Franz Kafka
    • Immanuel Kant
    • Byron Katie
    • Nikos Kazantzakis
    • John Keats
    • John F. Kennedy
    • Kibir
    • Stephen King
    • Alfie kohn
    • Matt Kohn >
      • Pleiadian Broadcast ???
    • Jeff Koons
    • Jiddu Krishnamurti
    • Rama Krishna
    • Stanley Kubrick >
      • Stanley Kubrick
    • Llewellyn Vaughan Lee
    • Best of David Letterman
    • C S Lewis
    • Jack London
    • David Lynch
    • Anandamayi Ma
    • Ramana Maharshi
    • Nelson Mandela
    • Og Mandino/Greatest Salesman >
      • Og Mandino/Summary
    • Karl Marx >
      • Karl Marx
    • John Mayer
    • Bert McCoy Quotes
    • Connor McGregor
    • Herman Melville
    • Lionel Messi
    • Dan Millman >
      • Peaceful Warrior
    • Hsin Hsin Ming The Book of Nothing
    • Mooji #1 >
      • Mooji/Avadhuta Gita #2
      • Mooji / Video & Sayings #3
      • Mooji #4
      • Mooji #5
    • Bill Moyer
    • Henry Miller
    • Thelonious Monk
    • Van Morrison
    • Elon Musk >
      • Elon Musk
    • Caroline Myss
    • Nietzsche >
      • Nietzsche
    • Anais Nin
    • Nissargadatta >
      • Nissargadatta I Am That
      • Nisargadatta Maharaj
    • John Oliver
    • John O'Donohue
    • Suze Orman
    • George Orwell >
      • 1984
      • 1984 >
        • george orwell biography
        • 1984 #1
    • Osho
    • Papaji
    • Pablo Picasso
    • Plato
    • Edgar Allen Poe
    • William Sydney Porter
    • Premananda
    • Marcel Proust
    • Anthony Robbins >
      • Tony Robbins
    • Robert Reich
    • Sen no Rikyu/Zen
    • Jim Rohn
    • Teddy Roosevelt quotes >
      • Victorian Period (1833-1901) >
        • Victorian Era
        • Robert Browning
        • Charles Dickens
        • Edgar Allen Poe
        • Alfred Lord Tennyson
    • Don Miguel Ruiz/The 4 Agreements
    • Rumi >
      • Rumi/Dr. Omid Safi
      • Rumi/Coleman Barks #1
      • Rumi/Coleman Barks #2
      • Rumi/Coleman Barks #3
      • Rumi/Coleman Barks #4
    • Bertrand Russell
    • Sadhguru #1 >
      • Sadhguru #2
      • Sounds of Isha #3
      • Sounds of Isha
      • Isha
    • Stefan Sagmeister
    • Joel Salatin
    • Samarpan
    • Michael Sandel
    • Dr. Seus
    • Shakespeare
    • Anoushka Shankar
    • Percy Bysshe Shelley >
      • Mary Shelly
    • Nickolas Sparks
    • Bruce Springsteen
    • Ralph Steadman
    • David Steindl-Rast
    • Robert Louis Stevenson >
      • Rober Louis Stevenson 2
      • Robert Louis Stevenson 3 >
        • Robert Louis Stevenson Poems
        • Jekyll/2007
        • Dr> Jekyll and Mr. Hyde Audio $$ >
          • Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (Videos)
          • Key Facts
        • Treasure Island/RLS
    • Teal Swan
    • Rabindrath Tagore
    • Henry David Thoreau
    • Nikola Tesla
    • Eckhart Tolle
    • Leo Tolstoy
    • Brian Tracy
    • Mark Twain
    • Irina Tweedie
    • Lao Tzu/Tao/The Way
    • Ludwig van Beethoven
    • Swami Vivekananda
    • Llewellyn Vaughan-Lee
    • Kurt Vonnegut
    • David Foster Wallace >
      • David Foster Wallace
    • Neale Donald Walsch
    • George Washington
    • Holocaust/Night/Elie Weisel >
      • Night/Elie Weisel #2 >
        • Elie Weisel Pictures
    • Orson Welles
    • Oscar Wilde
    • Walt Whitman
    • Marianne Williamson >
      • Marianne Williamson
      • Marianne Williamson
    • Ed Witten
    • John Wooden
    • William Wordsworth
    • W B Yeats
    • Zig Ziglar
    • Zizek
  • English 9
    • Week 1-4/ Uncovering the Self >
      • Uncovering the Self
    • Grade 9/Unit 1/ Writing Task
    • Grade 9/Unit 2
    • Grade 9/Unit 3
    • English 9/Unit 4
    • English 9 TEDs
    • English 3D
    • English 3D
    • Read 180/Intensive 2
  • TED
    • TED Talks >
      • Videos #34 >
        • Videos #35
        • Videos #36
        • Videos #37
        • Videos #38
      • ted talks
      • TED #2
      • TED #3
      • TED X
      • TedxWomen
    • Ted Ed >
      • TED.Ed #1
      • Ted Ed #2
      • Ted Ed #3
      • Ted Ed #4
      • Ted Ed #5
      • Ted Ed #6
      • TED Ed #8
  • Poetry
    • Haiku >
      • Haiku
    • Quotes on Poetry >
      • Poets on Poetry
    • TED Poetry >
      • Rives Poetry >
        • Beats
    • Poetry Images
    • Button Poetry
    • Our Life In Poetry
    • Poetry "Random"
    • Fredrico Lorca
  • Music
    • John lennon
    • Rolling Stones
    • Light in Babylon
    • Resham Firiri/ Nepal
    • Guitar
    • Estas Tonne
    • Andres Segovia/ Guitar
    • Anna RF
    • Gipsy Kings
    • Hindi Songs
    • Music #2
    • JAZZ/ Louis Armstrong
    • Blues
    • The Beatles
    • om
    • Jack Johnson
    • Jazz
    • NPR Music
    • Krishna Das
  • Philosophy
    • Economics >
      • Economic Philosophy
    • Existentialism Quotes >
      • Hegel
    • The School of Life
  • Untitled
  • Letters of Note Website
  • Awakening
  • Mantras
  • Google
  • Last Minute Substitute Ideas
  • linguistics
  • Short Stories
    • The Emperor's Three Questions
    • Short Stories
    • Sonata for Harp and Bicycle by Joan Aiken
    • Carry Your Own Skis by Lian Dolan >
      • Snowboard Playlist/mix
    • The Gift of the Magi/O. Henry
    • The Necklace/Maupassant
    • The Most Dangerous Game/Connell
  • Novels
    • Catcher in the Rye
    • I know Why the Caged Bird Sings
    • Lord of the Flies
    • Of Mice and Men
    • A Single Shard
    • Stargirl/ >
      • Jerry Spinelli
      • Stargirl/ Characters
  • Comedy
  • Google Project Street Art
  • HAARP
  • People Are Awesome
  • Health Care
  • Fracking
  • Girls in Sports/Gender Equality
  • Untitled
  • Music/Sufi
    • History of the Blues
    • Sufi Music
  • Literature Analysis
  • Avadhuta Gita .pdf
  • Rumi/Deepak Chopra
  • Present Moment/The Now/The Zone
  • English Language Explained/Maps
  • How to trademark a phrase!
  • Narration and Literature
  • Mahatria
  • Teaching Stories
  • Harlem Renaissance Music/and some Sara Vaughan
    • Harlem Renaissance Doc
  • Oasis of the Seas
  • Ap History Exam Prep
  • Advertising Techniques
  • Academic Literary Terms
  • Untitled
    • Untitled
  • Happiness 1
    • Happiness 2
    • How to get Happy!
    • Philosophy, A guide to Happiness
    • Toxic People
    • A Guide to Happiness (Philosophy)
    • The Power of Time Off
  • Pierre Bezuhov/From War and Peace
  • Writing
    • 25 Phrases That Are Said Wrong
    • Writing Advice/ Roberto Bolano >
      • George Orwell/ Why I Write
    • Grammar >
      • Pronouns Overused
      • Nouns
      • Punctuation
    • Writing/Journaling >
      • Journaling/Goalsetting >
        • Journaling
        • 180 Journaling Prompts
        • 100 Benefits of Journaling
        • Colgate's Living Writers
      • Cool Stuff to Journal About >
        • Big Think >
          • Big Thinks
        • Sanskrit Terms
        • Spirit Animals/Totems >
          • Power Animals
        • Hip-Hop
        • Met-Publications
        • Google "Art Project"
        • Old Guys Telling Jokes
        • Vimeo
        • UFO >
          • DARPA
          • Area 51
        • Videos 1-10 >
          • Videos #1
          • Videos #2
          • Videos #3
          • Videos #4
          • Videos #5
          • Videos #6
          • Videos #7
          • Videos #8
          • Videos #9
          • Videos #10 >
            • Videos 11-20 >
              • Videos #11
              • Videos #12
              • Videos #14
              • Videos #15
              • Videos #16
              • Videos #17
              • Videos #18
              • Videos #19
              • Videos #20
            • Videos #21-30 >
              • Videos #21
              • Videos #22
              • Videos #23
              • Videos #24
              • Videos #25
              • Videos #26
              • Videos #27
              • Videos #28
              • Videos #29
              • Videos #30
              • Videos 31-40 >
                • Videos #31
                • Videos #32
                • Videos #33
      • MIT Writing/Reading Class Syllabus
      • The Art of War
    • Writing
    • Literacy
    • Arguementative Essay Writing
    • Writing Tips
    • Some writers on writing >
      • Ayn Rand
    • Best Essays Ever!
    • How To Write
    • Writing Advice
    • "Quick Writes"
    • Expository Writing
    • CAHSEE Essay
    • Collection of "How to write" videos
    • Common Errors in Writing
    • Grammar #1 >
      • Grammar
      • Adverbial Clause
    • Composition Forum
    • Symbolism
    • Final Essay Resources
  • Environmental/Health Designs/Concerns
    • Environment
    • Health Care
    • Sugar/Poison
    • Digital Citizenship Cyberbullying 6/15 >
      • Risky Relationships On-line
      • Digital Footprint
    • Environment >
      • Water
      • Plastic Water Bottles 1
      • Plastic Water Bottles 2
      • Fluoridation
      • Fluoride
      • Cell Phones Cause Cancer
      • Oil/Tar Sands
      • Treehugger.com
      • hand sanitizer
      • Skin Lotions
    • RSA Videos
    • crashcourse! >
      • crashcourse 2!
    • Environmental
    • Design in a Nutshell >
      • Design
      • Designers
      • Open-University Bike Design
    • Beauty Industry Modeling
    • Minute Physics >
      • Minute Physics 2
    • How it's Made
    • Make:
    • Etsy Art and Culture
    • PBS Off/Soft Book
    • Iron-on Transfers
  • Cool Stuff to Write About!
    • Writers on Writing
    • Writer's Block...HaHa
    • Soccer >
      • Soccer
    • Amazing
    • Medicine/Doc Mike Evans
    • Mysteries & Scandals
    • Sex Education >
      • Teen Pregnancy
    • Tax The Rich?
    • The Creators Project >
      • The Creators Project
    • Harvard Thinks Big
    • Coffee
    • Art Misc >
      • MTV unplugged
    • Pulp Magazine Project
    • Thinker
    • Gun Control
    • Suicide
    • Citizen Hearing on Disclosure 2013
    • Witness Testimony
    • Ufo
    • Archaeology
    • The Truth About...
    • Helping Others
    • New Yorker Cartoons
    • Prostetics
    • Astronaut
    • Creators Project
    • Wearable Project
    • Minecraft
    • Archives/Various
    • Upworthy
    • Reincarnation
    • Undocumented
  • Character/ How to build it!
    • Red Frost/ Motivation
    • Confidence
    • Responsibility
    • Decision Making
  • Untitled
  • bio.com
  • The Science of Happiness
  • Gnostic Society Library
  • Sign Language Hip Hop
  • Summer Reading 2015
    • Nothing to Envy by Barbara Demick
  • Summer School 2015
    • Is Google making us stupid?
    • Does Technology Make Us Smarter?
  • News Reporting/Reading Same Script
  • English 12a
    • Unit 1 Week (1 & 2) "Summer Reading Assignment: Unbroken by Laura Hillenbrand" >
      • Unbroken Characters
      • Unbroken/ Prezi
    • Unit 3 Week (6-10) "Value of Life"
    • Unit 4 Week (9-12) "Racial Profiling"
  • Understanding Stress
  • Untitled
  • Drums and Drummers
  • Boy Scouts
    • Boy Scout Merit Badge Info
    • Climbing Knots/Boy Scouts
  • Unbroken
    • Unbroken Vocabulary
    • Unbroken Characters
    • Unbroken Discussion Questions
    • louie Zamperini and the 1936 Olympics
    • Louie Zamperini goes to War
    • Hiroshima
    • Unbroken - Louis Zamperini Story - ZAMP and HIS SUPER MAN B-24
    • Unbroken - Louis Zamperini Story - B-24s IN COMBAT
    • How Accurate is the movie Unbroken?
    • Unbroken - Louis Zamperini Story - SUPER MAN ATTACKS - FUNAFUTI and NAURU
    • Unbroken - Louis Zamperini Story - A GREEN HORNET and GREY SHARKS
    • Unbroken - Louis Zamperini Story - PRISON CAMPS - OFUNA and OMORI
    • Unbroken - Louis Zamperini Story - NAOETSU and CAMP B-4
    • Unbroken - Louis Zamperini Story - THE BIRD - THEN AND LATER
    • Unbroken - Louis Zamperini Story - WHEN LOUIE MET BILLY
    • Unbroken - Louis Zamperini Story - FORGIVENESS
    • Unbroken vs History
    • USA/Japan POWs
    • Norden Bombsight
    • B-24 Bomber
    • Can We Drink Salt Water?
    • Unbroken - Louis Zamperini Story - KWAJALEIN - EXECUTION ISLAND
  • Romeo & Juliet/ Classical Music/Deep Purple, Etc,..
  • How to be Happy!
  • Thoughts
  • J.K. Rowlings
  • James Patterson/ Writing
  • Business Planning
  • Personal Statement
    • www.essayhell.com
    • Show not Tell in Writing
    • Map Out The College App Essay
  • The Value of Life
    • John Paul Sartre/ bad faith
    • Addicted to Suffering/ Red Ribbon 2015
    • Actuarial Table
    • Value of Life Quotes
    • Ric Elias
    • Matt Whoolery/ How to be Unhappy
    • Jill Bolte Taylor
    • What Makes a Life Worth Living?
    • "What is a Life Worth?" AmandaRipley
  • Top Business Movie Speeches
  • Overcoming Hopelessness
  • Upcoming Movies to Watch!!
  • Finding Your Life Purpose
  • 20 Free Tools for Entrepreneurs
  • www.recitethis.com
  • Best Websitesfor Teaching 201 5
  • Best Websites for Teaching 2014
  • Best Websites for Teaching 2013
  • Test of Three
  • What I Wish I Knew In High School
  • Best Practices
  • Value of Life 11/15
  • 8 Iconic Movie Rules To Live By
  • Kathryn Schulz/ On Being Wrong
  • Dealing With Anger
  • Learning The Stock Market
  • What To Do in Your Life
  • TED Talks
  • Poetry of Perception/ Harvard
  • New Page
  • funniest jokes
  • Opinion Paper Basics
  • Found Poems for, Into The Wild
  • willpower
  • schoolofthought.org
  • Marc & Angel
  • Restorative Justice
  • Coloring Books
  • Verbal Workout/Vocab from books
  • http://www.ethosconsultancynz.com/
  • Pindex
  • Understanding Assignments
  • Slavery
  • Commencement Speeches
  • Writing Prompts
  • Personal Statement
  • English 12 Writing Prompts
  • Block Letter Format
  • PIQ
  • El Toro High School Class of 1979
  • SNL
  • Blackout Poems
  • Nerdwriter1
  • Internet Movie Script Database
  • Unit 5
  • Product Placement in Films
  • Tablets of Destiny
  • Public Service Videos
  • Instramental Beats For Poetry
  • Sexual Innuendos
  • Animal Totems
  • English 9 Ted Talks
  • Animal Farm
  • John F. Kennedy 3
  • How to be Happy?
  • The Boiling Frog Story
  • Lord Of The Flies
  • 2017 Summer Reading
  • Fashion History
  • Ayahuasca
  • Russian Dystopian Novel "We" George Orwell/Aldous Huxley
  • Smart Websites
    • 99U.com
  • Before I Fall
  • Mark Knopfler
  • Quotes on Manners
  • Eng 12/ Good Food Bad Food
  • Summer Reading 2017
  • New Page
  • Live and Learn by Louise Menand
  • How to write an essay?
    • Vanderbilt Writing Resources
  • Ishmael Nazario
  • False Flags False attacks
  • Millikan Soccer Team
    • Possession Soccer
  • White Sounds for feeling Good
  • Food Unit English 12b
  • 1984 (New 2018)
    • 1984 Vocabulary Words
  • Are we living in the Matrix?
  • Stand-up Poetry
  • Sativacation
  • McCoy Family History
  • Summer Bridge 2018
  • The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian by Sherman Alexie
  • Concept Attainment
  • Get Rid of PTSD with a Stellate Ganglion Block
  • English 9 2018-19
  • 9/11
  • Chef Jeremiah Tower
  • Correy Goode
  • How to get out of jury duty
  • Rupi Kaur Poet
  • Greek Stuff to journal about
  • Romeo and Juliet
  • Should You Use "I"?
  • The Odyssey Explained
  • Field of Dreams
  • Advice to your younger self
  • The Boiling Frog Story
  • GATE Students
  • 30 Things You Can Do To Promote Creativity
  • GATE Students in the Visual arts
  • Meditation
  • Boy Scout Eagle Project Information
  • Hunter S Thompson
  • Character Development
  • How to spot a liar
  • The History of Drunk
  • How to Draw Like an architect
  • Cool Interviews
  • Ouija Board Origins
    • Ouija Board Origins
  • Free Writing Courses
  • How to Make Change in the World
  • The Vatican
  • Stanford Soccer
  • UCI Soccer
  • D1 College Soccer
  • Invasion of the Body Snatchers 1978
  • Artist Videos
  • Art
  • Ai Weiwei
  • Jannis Kounelles
  • Jose Luis Malo
  • 2020 - 21 School Year
  • Bert McCoy Quotes
WTC Victims: What's A Life Worth?By Amanda Ripley Wednesday, Feb. 06, 2002



    • inShare
  • Read Later

NINA BERMAN/AURORA FOR TIMEMaureen Halvorson, widow of James Halvorson


  • Email
  • Print
  • Share
  • Reprints
Follow @TIME


A train barreled over Joseph Hewins' body on a wintry evening in 1845 in the Massachusetts Berkshires. Hewins had spent the workday shoveling snow off the tracks, only to be killed on his trip back to town when a switchman got distracted. Hewins left behind a wife and three children, who were poor even before his death. His widow sued but lost at every level. Had the train merely chopped off Hewins' leg, the railroad would have paid. But in the perverse logic of that time, when a man died, he took his legal claims with him. And so the thinking went for most of the century, until something unheard of began to happen. The courts started to put a dollar value on a life--after death.The concept of assigning a price tag to a life has always made people intensely squeamish. After all, isn't it degrading to presume that money can make a family whole again? And what of the disparities? Is a poor man's life worth less than a rich man's? Over the past 100 years, U.S. courts have crafted their answers to these questions. Forensic economists testify on the value of a life every day. They can even tell you the average valuation of an injured knee (about $200,000). But until now, the public at large has not had to reckon with the process and its imperfections. Until the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11 created a small city's worth of grieving families and the government established an unprecedented fund to compensate them, the mathematics of loss was a little-known science. Now the process is on garish display, and it is tempting to avert the eyes.

On the morning of Jan. 18, about 70 family members file into the rows of crimson seats at the Norwalk, Conn., city hall auditorium. They listen quietly to special master Kenneth Feinberg, whom the government has entrusted with dispersing its money to those most affected by the Sept. 11 tragedy. His first job is to persuade them to join the federal Victim Compensation Fund, the country's largest experiment in paying mass victims and their families without placing blame. The effort is being closely watched for the precedents it will set.

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Much has been made of the enormous charity funds raised after the attacks. Donations to those groups do funnel thousands of dollars to the victims' families — in particular, the families of fire fighters and police officers. But overall, the nearly $2 billion in charity money is chump change compared with the cash that will flow out of government coffers. There is no limit to the federal fund, but the tab is likely to be triple the size of the charity pot. And while charity funds are doled out to a vast pool of people, including businesses hurt by the attacks, the government money will go exclusively to the injured and to families of the deceased.

Feinberg, in a black-and-white polka-dot tie, speaks in short, punchy sentences and a loud voice. He has already given the speech 32 times up and down the East Coast. The main thrust: The government, for the first time ever, has agreed to write large checks to victims' families without any litigation. The checks will arrive within four months after a claim is filed--no legal fees, no agonizing 10-year lawsuit. But every award will be based on a cold calculus, much the way courts handle wrongful-death claims.

That means different sums for different families. In a TIME/CNN poll taken last month, 86% said all families should receive the same amount. But that's not how it's going to work.

The calculus has several steps, Feinberg explains. First, the government will estimate how much a victim would have earned over his or her lifetime had the planes never crashed. That means a broker's family will qualify for a vastly higher award than a window washer's family. To estimate this amount, each family was handed an easy-to-read chart on the way into the meeting: Find your loved one's age and income and follow your finger to the magic number. Note that the lifetime earnings have been boosted by a flat $250,000 for "pain and suffering"--noneconomic losses, they are called. Tack on an extra $50,000 in pain and suffering for a spouse and for each child. The charts, while functional, are brutal, crystallizing how readily the legal system commodifies life.

Then — and this is crucial — don't get too excited. That first number may be quite high — in the millions for many. But you must, according to the rules of the fund, subtract all the money you are getting from other sources except charities. A court settlement would not be diminished this way, but this is not a court, Feinberg repeatedly points out. Deduct life insurance, pension, Social Security death benefits and workers' compensation. Now you have the total award the government is offering you for your loss.

The deductions have the effect of equalizing the differences in the awards. Critics have called this Feinberg's "Robin Hood strategy." For many people in the room, the number is now at or close to zero. Feinberg says he will make sure no one gets zero. "Leave it to me," he says. But nowhere will that be written into the rules when they are finalized in mid-February. Likewise, many fiances and gay partners will be at the mercy of Feinberg's discretion in seeking awards. Before finding out exactly what they will get — and the rules are complex — families will have to agree never to sue anyone for the attacks. "Normally, that would be a difficult call," says Feinberg. "Not here. The right to sue in this case is simply not a reasonable alternative."
That's because Congress has capped the liability of the airlines, the airport owners, the aircraft manufacturers, the towers' landlord and the city of New York. In the name of the economy, the government severely restricted the victims' rights to sue — whether they join the fund or not. It is this lack of a viable option, even if they would not take it, that galls many families.


Congress created the fund as a safety net for the victims' families, to ensure that they maintain something resembling their current standard of living — whether they get assistance from private insurance or government money. The families see it as so much more. For the traumatized, the charts are like a Rorschach test. Some view the money as a halfhearted apology for the breakdown in security and intelligence that made the attacks possible. Others can't help seeing the award as a callous measure of their loved one's value. Many regard it as a substitute for the millions they think they may have got in court, had the liability not been capped. When the total comes out to be underwhelming, these families take it personally. There's a fundamental clash between the way they interpret the purpose of the fund and the way the government sees it.

After Feinberg speaks, he stands back and braces himself for an artillery of angry rhetorical questions. Gerry Sweeney, whose brother died in Tower 2, Floor 105, points at Feinberg and explains why $250,000 is not enough for pain and suffering in the case of her now fatherless nephew. "Have you ever seen a 12-year-old have a nervous breakdown?" she asks. Another woman concocts an analogy to illustrate for Feinberg what it was like to talk to loved ones as they came to accept their imminent, violent deaths and to watch the towers collapse on live TV. "If your wife was brutally raped and murdered and you had to watch and listen to it happen, what would you think the right amount would be?" Finally, Maureen Halvorson, who lost her husband and her brother, speaks up from the front row in a quiet, bewildered voice. "I just can't accept the fact that the Federal Government is saying my husband and my brother are worth nothing." Feinberg is silent.

The more than 3,000 victims of the Sept. 11 attacks are frozen in snapshots, wide-smiling men and women in crisp suits and uniforms who liked to build birdhouses on weekends and play practical jokes. In the literature of grief, they have become hardworking innocents, heroes and saints. But those they left behind are decidedly human. Some compete with others for most bereaved status; others demand an apology even when no one is listening. Some are popping pills, and others cannot leave the house. Most days, they are inconsolable. And as the rest of the country begins to ease back into normalcy, these families stand, indignant, in the way.

Already, some Americans have lost patience with them. "My tax money should not be given to someone with a $750,000 mortgage to pay who needs a set of fresh, matching towels in her bathroom every season," one person wrote anonymously to the Department of Justice's Web page on victim compensation. "I'm shocked and appalled and very disappointed," wrote a Florida resident, "that some individuals are living in such a rare and well-gilded ivory tower that they feel $250,000 is not sufficient compensation. Most of us, the working people of America, make $20,000 to $40,000 per year. Where do these wealthy, spoiled, greedy folks in New York get off, pretending that what happened to them was so uniquely horrible? I'm over it. Yeah, it was unique. Yeah, it was horrible. Yeah, I sent money to help. And after reading about them suing for more money, I begin to regret it."

It's true that some families' behavior has been less than dignified. The divorced parents of a woman killed in the Pentagon, who are eligible for money because their daughter left no dependents, have filed competing claims. Lawyers are now involved. Says her father: "I guarantee she loved her daddy as much as she loved her mom. I feel that I'm entitled to something."

And it's also a fact that these families will get more money from charities and the government combined than anyone has so far received after the Oklahoma City bombing or the 1998 bombing of the Nairobi embassy. For that matter, if these victims had been killed in a drive-by shooting, they probably would not have received more than a few thousand dollars from state victim-compensation funds.
That fact is not lost on the public, particularly people whose relatives have died in everyday tragedies. At the Wichita Eagle in Kansas, editorial-page director Phil Brownlee has received calls and letters from locals disgusted by the families' complaints, and he agrees. "It's just frustrating that the goodwill demonstrated by the government seems to be deteriorating," he says. "Now you've got families who are upset with what most Americans deem to be generous contributions. It's the loss of the spirit of Sept. 11, the souring of that sense of solidarity."


But it may not be fair to compare Sept. 11 with a street crime or even Oklahoma City. After all, these recent attacks involved an orchestrated, simultaneous security breach on four airplanes, carried out by 19 men who had been living and training on our soil. A better comparison might be past international terrorist attacks and plane crashes. Those that have been resolved — and that's a major distinction — do show higher payouts than the average amount likely to come out of the Sept. 11 federal fund.

In 25 major aviation accidents between 1970 and 1984, the average compensation for victims who went to trial was $1 million in current dollars, according to a Rand Corp. analysis. Average compensation for cases settled without a lawsuit was $415,000. The biggest aviation payout in history followed the crash of Pan Am Flight 103 over Lockerbie, Scotland, in 1988. Settlements ranged all over the spectrum, with a couple dozen exceeding $10 million, according to Manhattan attorney Lee Kreindler, who acted as lead counsel. Dividing the total $500 million payout over the 270 victims yields an average award of $1.85 million. However, the families had to hand about a third of their awards to their lawyers, and they waited seven to eight years to see any money. And the families of the six people killed in the 1993 World Trade Center bombing are still waiting for their day in civil court.

In the end, most families will probably choose the fund over litigation. The Lockerbie millions are simply not a realistic possibility. It is always extremely difficult to sue the government. And the liability for the Sept. 11 attacks was capped by Congress at about $1.5 billion per plane. So while the families of those killed in the Pennsylvania and Pentagon crashes may have enough to go around, there are far too many victims in New York. "The court model works perfectly when you don't have $50 billion in damages or 3,000 deaths," says Leo Boyle, a Boston lawyer and president of the Association of Trial Lawyers of America, which supports the fund option and has lined up more than 2,000 attorneys to offer free help navigating its rules. Even without the caps, Boyle insists, victims could not have extracted more money by putting United and American Airlines through bankruptcy. So far, only a handful of suits have been filed.

In any event, there was no talking Congress out of the liability caps when it drafted the airline-bailout package 10 days after the attacks. The airlines could not fly without insurance, and their coverage was far short of what it would take to pay the damages. Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan privately told congressional leaders that getting the planes up again was the single biggest "multiplier" that could revive the economy on every level. So the Democrats, who usually balk at limiting the ability to sue, accepted the idea of an airline bailout — as long as it came with a mechanism to compensate victims. Oklahoma Senator Don Nickles, the No. 2 Republican in the Senate and a longtime proponent of tort reform, pushed hard to limit how much the victims' families could claim, but he did not prevail.

But once the interim rules were drawn up by Feinberg's office — in conjunction with the Department of Justice and the Office of Management and Budget — there were some surprises. In particular, the figures for pain and suffering astonished some who had backed the fund. "The numbers are low by any measure," says Boyle. Feinberg says he chose the $250,000 figure because that's how much beneficiaries receive from the Federal Government when fire fighters and police die on the job. The additional $50,000 for the spouse and each child is, he admits, "just some rough approximation of what I thought was fair." He calls the fund "rough justice."

The American Tort Reform Association, backed mostly by Republicans, has been lobbying since 1986 to limit noneconomic damages in some suits to $250,000. John Ashcroft, head of the Justice Department, pushed for such a cap on punitive damages when he was a Senator. But Feinberg, a Democrat, insists he was not pressured by the Administration to keep the numbers low.

No matter how many times tearful widows accuse him of protecting the airlines, Feinberg does not blush. A lawyer with decades of experience in the messy art of compromise (Feinberg was special master for the $180 million distributed to veterans exposed to Agent Orange), he is accustomed to rage. "On Tuesday I get whacked for this or that in New Jersey. The next day it's New York. It goes with the job." But he rejects the theory that greed is a factor. "People have had a loved one wrenched from them suddenly, without warning, and we are only five months beyond that disaster. It was nearly yesterday. And they are desperately seeking, from what I've seen, to place as much of a value on that lost loved one as they can. So here is where they seek to amplify the value of that memory. They do it by saying we want more, as a validation of the loss. That's not greed. That's human nature."
Susan and Harvey Blomberg of Fairfield County, Conn., have been to three meetings on the victim-compensation fund, even though, as parents of a victim who has left a wife and kids behind, they are not in line for compensation. The rules give preference to the victim's spouse and children. But the Blombergs come to these meetings to be part of something, to be counted. And they linger after everyone else has left. "My daughter-in-law was upset when we went to the meetings," Susan says. "She said, 'It's not really about you. It's about the widows and children.' And I said, 'I want more information.' You can't compare grief, because nobody can get inside you. But I feel like an orphan. When they did this formula, why didn't they consider the parents? My daughter-in-law was married for five years. We had Jonathan for 33 years."


"It's a horrible thing that this is where our energies need to be pulled," says Cheri Sparacio, 37, the widow of Thomas Sparacio, a currency trader at Euro Brokers who died in Tower 2. In their modest house in Staten Island, littered with the toys of her twin two-year-olds, she explains why she sees the estimated $138,000 she would get from the fund as a cheap bribe. "The government is not taking any responsibility for what it's done. This was just one screw-up after another." She is also worried about her financial stability; in less than a month, she will have their third child. Thomas was the primary wage earner, although Cheri worked as a part-time school psychologist until Sept. 11. She doesn't see how she can go back to work with an infant and two toddlers unless she hires full-time help. "Please, come step into my shoes for a minute," she says, her eyes flat and unblinking. "I am not looking to go to Tahiti."

But uptown in the apartment where Samuel Fields once lived, the fund acts like a quiet equalizer, a way for the government to guarantee that victims with less insurance emerge with basic support. Fields was a security guard for six years in Tower 1. He made $22,000 a year and lived with his family in a housing project in Harlem. On Sept. 11, he helped people evacuate the building and then went back inside to help some more. Fields never came home. Next month his widow Angela will give birth to their fifth child. Because Fields made a small salary, his family's preliminary award is less than Sparacio's. But his family's deductions are also smaller. In the end, Angela's estimated $444,010 award will probably be three times the size of Cheri's.

In valuing different lives differently — the first part of the equation — the fund follows common legal practice. Courts always grant money on the basis of a person's earning power in life. That's because the courts are not attempting to replace "souls," says Philip Bobbitt, a law professor at the University of Texas who has written about the allocation of scarce resources in times of tragedy. "We're not trying to make you psychologically whole. Where we can calculate the loss is in economic loss." The Feinberg plan differs from legal norms in deducting the value of life insurance and pensions. Also, it allows no flexibility in determining noneconomic damages. In court, pain and suffering would be weighed individually.

Money aside, a lawsuit can be an investigative device like no other, forcing answers about what led to a death. Some Sept. 11 families say they might file suit for that reason alone, even if they never get a dime. And for other families, there is enormous value in no lawsuits at all. David Gordenstein lost his wife, Lisa Fenn Gordenstein, on American Flight 11. "Am I sad? I've had my heart torn out," he says. But he would rather devote his life to raising his two young daughters than pursuing a lawsuit. He will probably file a claim with the federal fund, which he acknowledges is not perfect. "I am proud of what my country tried to do. I think the intention is noble."

The night before Lisa died, she slipped a clipping under the door of David's home office, something she often did. It was a saying from theologian Charles Swindoll that read, "Attitude, to me, is more important than facts. It is more important than the past, than education, than money, than circumstances, than failures, than successes, than what other people think or say or do...It will make or break a company, a church, a home." David read it at her memorial. And while he jokes that it's kind of cliched — "typical Lisa" — he says he thinks its message might help carry his family through this.


Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.